So many options, but here are a few:
Anchor Cafe
Yah Yahs Cafe
Alquimista
Tierra Viva
Miscelanea
Organi-K
Cafe El Espresso
Most spots offer both lunch and dinner!
Naty’s Cocina
Baklava
Alto Alto
Gaby’s Tacos
Pizza Venezia
Don Juan's
La Rustica
Mary’s Restaurant
Northside Cafe
Bichos Tacos
Xochi
At The Dock
Casa Lvnae*
Tacos Tal Ivan
Casa de Chile Relleno
El Italiano Sayulita
The Sports Garden
Tropical House
Yambak Brewery
Don Pedro's
The Embers
Goat Beach Club
Sayulita Public House
Escondido Bar
Stogie's Cigar & Cocktail Lounge
Lucid
Sur38
Bar Don Pato's
For something sweet:
Rollado Ice Cream
Chocobanana
Sayu Swirls